To allow people to specialize on one task trade is needed. If all you do is build clocks you are going to have to trade clocks for other stuff that is needed to keep you alive, like food and shelter. Trading stuff directly is inefficient. What happens if the guy raising pigs already has a working clock? You would have to do a bunch of intermediate trades to get hold of something he wants before you could get some meat. What is needed is an intermediate that is accepted by everyone, that way the maximum number of trades becomes two, one to get the intermediate and one to get what you want.
Gold has for a long time been the preferred intermediate. The properties of gold are a good match for this purpose, it is rare and easy to identify. Because it's rare it will have a high value, which means you won't have to carry around a lot of it, and if someone gives you a really heavy yellow metal you can be sure it is mostly gold, making everyone more at ease when trading.
The next invention was paper money and banks. By keeping all the gold with one trusted entity and instead trading with paper money that represented a certain amount of gold a lot of the downsides of gold disappeared. No need to worry about the purity of the gold you are receiving, or dividing and weighing it, or storing it in a secure way, just a lot more convenient. Of course you now had to trust the central entity that issued the paper money and held all the gold.
Gold being both a currency and a long term asset causes problems. One can see the total gold supply as being split between long term use and short term use (as a currency). If long term use increases the amount of gold available for short term use decreases, causing deflation, and vice versa. So if people start saving more we get deflation, and if people start spending their savings we see inflation. This flaw combined with human herd mentality caused enough price variations for people to start looking for a fix to this problem.
The fix for the price instability was to disconnect the paper money from gold to be able to adjust the amount of money in circulation, and to introduce a constant growth in the money supply making it unsuitable for long term use. The central bank would lend out fresh money to increase the money supply and when it wanted to shrink the money supply it would increase the interest rates on the previous loans and just destroy the money that flowed in.
With that we have reached the system that is used in all (?) countries today. Have all the problems been solved? Looking at the prices of consumables in the US it does look promising. The dollar was disconnected from gold in 1971 and excluding the first few years after the change the prices have been relatively stable, although its not exactly a perfectly straight line.
I think there are two problems with the current system. The first problem is that the money the central bank is trying to inject into the system does not immediately hit the consumables market, there is a delay between action and effect which makes the whole system difficult to control. As mentioned earlier the injection of money is done when new loans are taken, but most loans nowadays are for buying real estate, not for buying consumables, so the money has to travel all the way from relatively few real estate buyers to the consumables market before the desired effect happens.
The second problem is that the current system requires constant inflation to dissuade people from saving in currency. I think constant inflation is harmful for society as it makes it hard to see how prices evolve over time. Being able to intuitively answer questions like "Am I making more money now than 10 years ago?", "Are my heating bills larger now than 10 years ago?" is important to be able to gauge if society is moving in the right or wrong direction, and make necessary adjustments.
When the system was conceived this was probably the best they could do, but things have changed since then. Digital money is now a possibility, which would give the central bank the ability to add or remove money from anyone's account at any time. This fine grained control over the money opens up new possibilities when trying to achieve price stability.
Lets imagine a system where the central bank adjusts the money supply by adding and removing money directly from peoples' accounts. How much money is added or removed depends on the average age of the money in the account, or to put it differently, how much action there is in the account. Accounts with a high average age will be punished by adding less money and removing more money when money supply adjustments are performed. In such a system I believe both of the previously mentioned problems would be solved.
When injecting money the money would be spread more evenly over the population which would likely make the money hit the consumables market more quickly, this in turn will make the whole system easier to control as there will be less latency between action and effect.
The new system discourages saving in currency without using constant inflation. This is because when you save in money the average age of your money will increase, which means you will be punished by the system at the next money supply adjustment by getting less fresh money or having the system take more money from you.
Sunday, April 19, 2020
Friday, April 10, 2020
Salary distribution Malmö/Lund area 2018
A few years ago I made a crude scan of "Taxeringkalendern", a book with peoples' salaries which is published yearly in Sweden. From that data I produced some statistics. The old post can be found at the following link
https://pytt3.blogspot.com/2016/12/are-you-getting-paid-enough-for-your.html
Now I've made the same thing again but with the latest "Taxeringskalendern", which contains data for 2018. The salary distribution in the Malmö/Lund area now looks as follows. To find out what salary you should have estimate the likelihood of finding someone equal or better than you in the workforce (everyone working, not just your profession), locate the likelihood on the y-axis and read out the salary you should have on the x-axis.
Looks like everyone is getting richer as the entire line is shifted to the right, towards higher salaries. If we look at individuals at specific positions on the y-axis we find the following numbers.
0.85: +3.2%
0.5: +6.6%
0.15: +7.8%
The higher the salary the more it has grown, ie the income gap is increasing.
The diagram is adjusted for inflation, so that we will not be fooled by the central bank's money printing, which drives up salaries but not our purchasing power. Unfortunately measuring inflation is difficult, so we can't trust the inflation figures 100%. Lets convert the salaries to euros and use ECB's inflation figures instead and check how it looks then. It will be like our three individuals from before work in Sweden but live in a euro country.
0.85: -8.4%
0.5: -5.4%
0.15: -4.4%
That paints quite a different picture of how things are progressing. The truth is probably somewhere in the middle.
The scripts used for the scanning and the diagram can be found here.
https://pytt3.blogspot.com/2016/12/are-you-getting-paid-enough-for-your.html
Now I've made the same thing again but with the latest "Taxeringskalendern", which contains data for 2018. The salary distribution in the Malmö/Lund area now looks as follows. To find out what salary you should have estimate the likelihood of finding someone equal or better than you in the workforce (everyone working, not just your profession), locate the likelihood on the y-axis and read out the salary you should have on the x-axis.
Looks like everyone is getting richer as the entire line is shifted to the right, towards higher salaries. If we look at individuals at specific positions on the y-axis we find the following numbers.
0.85: +3.2%
0.5: +6.6%
0.15: +7.8%
The higher the salary the more it has grown, ie the income gap is increasing.
The diagram is adjusted for inflation, so that we will not be fooled by the central bank's money printing, which drives up salaries but not our purchasing power. Unfortunately measuring inflation is difficult, so we can't trust the inflation figures 100%. Lets convert the salaries to euros and use ECB's inflation figures instead and check how it looks then. It will be like our three individuals from before work in Sweden but live in a euro country.
0.85: -8.4%
0.5: -5.4%
0.15: -4.4%
That paints quite a different picture of how things are progressing. The truth is probably somewhere in the middle.
The scripts used for the scanning and the diagram can be found here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

