Thursday, April 20, 2017

How large is the online drug market?

I think people buy bitcoins for primarily two reasons.
  1. To be able to by drugs online
  2. Speculation, thinking that the bitcoin value will be higher at some point in the future
Drug buyers probably make significantly smaller purchases of bitcoins than speculators. If this is true one can work out the intent of the bitcoin purchase (speculation or buying drugs) by looking at the size of the purchase.

Transaction logs from many bitcoin markets can be found at http://api.bitcoincharts.com/v1/csv/.


If we assume that bitcoin purchases smaller than or equal to 199USD are for buying drugs and purchases larger than 199USD are for speculation we get the following diagram.


2016 drugs for 512 million USD where bought through the USD->bitcoin->drugs path.

The over 1000% increase in drug purchases between 2012 and 2013 looks a bit suspicious. Can the market really grow that fast? Maybe there is some speculation, which can grow much faster than the drug market, going on in the <=199USD range. Automated speculation could operate in that range, but would be discouraged from doing so by rising transaction fee costs. Unfortunately the huge volume difference between the speculators and the drug buyers means that not many percent of the speculation volume needs to end up in the <=199USD range to severely corrupt my estimate of the online drug market size.

The previous model does not include drug purchases larger than 199USD, and there are likely quite a few of those. If we assume there was only drug trade and no speculation in 2012 we can use the 2012 transaction size distribution as a template for the "buying drugs" class.  This assumption is not completely crazy, in 2012 Silk Road had been online for almost a year so the drug trade was going on but bitcoin was not yet very well known so speculation was hopefully minimal. Fitting 2012's transaction size distribution onto 2016 looks as follows. The area under the green line is the drug trade, the rest is speculation.


The result of this model looks as follows.


2 billion USD 2016. Almost three times as much money is spent on drug purchases >199USD than purchases <=199USD. The most common bitcoin market transaction size for drug buyers is 500USD. There needs to be quite a lot of larger drug purchases for this to make sense, or there was more speculation in 2012 than I thought.

The huge increase between 2012 and 2013 is seen in this model also, which is expected as the fitting algorithm makes the same assumption as the previous model, that there is no speculation in the <=199USD range. If there is significant speculation in the <=199USD range the output of this model will be just as corrupt as the previous one.

People in the US spend ~100 billion USD on drugs every year (source) so 0.5-2% of the drugs pass through the online markets, if my numbers are correct.

RAND have also tried to estimate the size of the online drug market but with a different approach where they crawled some of the larger marketplaces for drugs and tried to get the information from the collected data (details). They got a worldwide yearly revenue of 253-300 million USD.

The big difference between my estimate and RAND's estimate is another indicator that there is significant speculation in the <=199USD range, probably from speculation bots, as proposed earlier. This makes my method a lot less reliable.

The script that generated all the diagrams can be found here.

No comments:

Post a Comment